When I first heard that this book is about students of the Classics, I myself being a student of English Literature, felt that I simply HAD to read it. So I began to read in the hopes that this novel would deal with things that I could resonate with and I wasn’t disappointed. This novel refers to the ways of the Greeks, the mythologies, religious beliefs, and histories. In doing so, the writing has an intellectual edge and I’m pleased to say I got what I wanted out of this book. But there’s so much going on in this book. There’s mystery, suspense, and quite a bit of thrill. Did I mention it gets pretty dark in places? After I was done reading this (I finished at the stroke of midnight) and I actually looked around a few times checking for ghosts in my dark room.
The first few pages painted a picture similar to the one I had witnessed in the film “Dead Poet’s Society.” A movie starring the loveable Robin Williams who plays the role of a lecturer of poetry. I absolutely LOVED this film. But this book was quite different and has its own uniqueness.
Here are a group of highly intellectual students cordoned off to spend a majority of their time taking classes from an erudite teacher. But underneath this seemingly normal facade, lurks disaster. What could possibly happen to this lot in order to plummet all of them into a dark abyss?
For the sensitive reader out there, here’s something to be aware of: This novel touches upon twincest, drugs, and cold-blooded murder.
I was surprised how the events in the novel made me respond on an emotional level. I felt for the characters, took pity on them and their state of helplessness. At times, I was gripped with fear for them while in other times, I was puzzled by the level of distance that the narrator Richard, seemed to have in the telling of the narrative.The subject matter of this novel really won me over. I have in the past, encountered groups of peers with an extreme passion for a subject. I have also witnessed the obsessiveness with which some scholarly and stoic individuals attempt to tackle the problems in their lives. The attempt to immerse oneself into the subject one has chosen to specialize in. This is exactly what the characters of The Secret History do. For instance, Henry and the twins, Charles and Camilla, really manage to live, breathe, and sleep Greek-The subject they are majoring in.
It makes clear that the distinction between intellectuality and sheer barbarism is but a thin line.
This novel provides us with a moral dilemma. It makes us question the correctness of some people’s actions/decisions. For instance, I was truly shocked at Julian’s and Henry’s level of eccentricity, their unconventional way of responding to situations they are faced with.
I felt that this novel could have been much more if Tartt had given us more background for the narrator, Richard. In the end, I felt like I didn’t know this character any more than I did at the start of the novel. I also hoped there was more information on the time period in which “The Secret History” takes place. I’m aware that this novel was set around 25 years ago but I found it difficult to place it within a particular time frame. Although from what I was able to gather, it is probably set in the period just after the Vietnam War.
What really appealed to me about this story was Tartt’s writing. Even though it is at times possible to predict what happens next in the plot, the process or manner in which her writing unravels this event is truly remarkable. This book had me sitting on the edge of my seat from the very beginning. Tartt’s writing is absorbing and expects a level of involvement on part of the reader. With every turn of the page, this novel simply draws you in. Tartt's has this manner of dropping hints about upcoming events and you know it’s going to happen soon, but you can do nothing as a reader except read on to find out what unfolds.
The characters are all well rounded and created with utmost care. Tartt’s decision to center the plot around seven main characters is an ambitious one, but she achieves this with flawlessness and ease.
The manner in which Tartt chooses to leave some events to the reader’s imagination in the course of this novel is what struck me as utterly brilliant. She only hints at them, leaving the rest up to the reader.
Tartt’s novel succeeds in its ability to absolutely dumbfound the reader, leave them speechless. The Secret History left me feeling only partially satiated. Nevertheless, I fell in love with it. This is the sort of book that must be read and re-read. But for now, I’m now looking forward to reading Tartt’s other works, The Little Friend, and The Goldfinch.
Although ‘The Secret History’ is let down by a relatively thin plot and some pacing issues, the writing and the atmosphere elevate it into a very good suspense.
For a book of its size, one would assume the presence of a substantial plot. The story is narrated by Richard, one of 6 students in a Classics class taught by a slightly mysterious and charismatic professor named Julian. The event around which the plot revolves is revealed to us very quickly in the first few pages. One of the main characters is murdered by the rest of the class. The story gradually builds-up to the murder and then unravels the consequences of that event.
Another problem with the book is the consistency in the pacing. The story is roughly told in 2 speeds: slow and fast. In the slow mode, a particular period like a fortnight or a couple of months are described in detail. In the fast mode, the progress of entire relationships evolve over a period of 3-4 months with only significant snippets showing us that change. This led to a bit of consistency. Richard remains distant from the others at times despite the fast mode suggesting that the group has successfully assimilated him.
Despite the minor problems, the writing really comes through. The author is wonderful at communicating the atmosphere and imaginative with the descriptions. The story flows smoothly and I finished the book in 5 relatively long sessions (so unlike me). The synopsis of the book listed above might be a misleading though. Although the professor is always a major figure, he is out of our vision for most of the book. The choices, motivations and actions of the 6 students that really drive the book.
One person found this helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?
This is one of the most absurd, ridiculous and outrageous cost I have ever seen! Really, Rs. 99/- delivery charges for an audio cassette?
Delivery Charge: While I have always been a huge fan of this author and will not blink twice before paying Rs. 1,78,972.06 for an unabridged, imported audio book in the form of an audio cassette, I find the 99 rupees delivery charges way too high. This charge is stopping me from purchasing this edition, something that I have wanted to own for quite a long time now.
EMI Option: On a side note, I am so grateful for the EMI option available for this product. I couldn’t believe my eyes when I found the “EMI Available” message right below the price. Can you image, I just have to pay Rs. 15,985.30 each month for a 12-months EMI. Yay!!!
Product Format: Who would have thought that one can get an audio book in the form of an audio cassette in these times? There were many a nights where I have laid in my bed, sleepless and thinking about the one thing that I wanted most in my life: this audio book in the form of a cassette. I had lost many of my worldly possessions over the unavailability of this version – my sleep, my health, a direction in my life. I can only thank my lucky stars for stumbling upon this cassette; my life would have never been lived to the fullest unless I have a copy of this! All I now need is to find a cassette player (in working condition) and one of my life’s foremost wishes will be fulfilled.
I don’t see an Amazon Bestseller rank on this product, a good indication that no one has bought this as yet. Dear publisher, please reduce the astronomical delivery charges to something that is more affordable, and I am positive that you will have more customers buying this product. Cheers!!!
6 people found this helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?