- Hardcover: 336 pages
- Publisher: Penguin Viking (5 December 2018)
- Language: English
- ISBN-10: 0670092096
- ISBN-13: 978-0670092093
- Package Dimensions: 23.2 x 15.4 x 4 cm
- Average Customer Review: 33 customer reviews
- Amazon Bestsellers Rank: #2,934 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Of Counsel: The Challenges of the Modi-Jaitley Economy Hardcover – 5 Dec 2018
Save Extra with 3 offers
- Cashback (4): Get 10% cashback up to Rs. 100 using Visa Signature or Visa Infinite cards. Shop during the Visa Shopping Days starting 20th to end of every month. Cashback within 3 days from shipment. Here's how
- Get 10% cashback using RuPay cards. Max Cashback - INR 100 if you are using RuPay card for first time on Amazon. INR 25 if you have used RuPay card earlier. Check here for your cashback eligibility Here's how
- Get 25% back up to Rs.50 using Amazon Pay UPI. For Android App customers only. Valid once during the offer period. Cashback within 10 days. Set up Amazon Pay UPI Here's how
- Get offers for up to ₹1375 cashback on MakeMyTrip, Redbus, UrbanClap, Faasos & 1Mg. Shop on Amazon between 19th Apr to 30th Apr 2019 to become eligible for the offer. T&C apply Here's how
- No Cost EMI: No Cost EMI available on Amazon Pay ICICI credit cards on orders above Rs. 3000 Here's how
- Bank Offer: 5% Instant Discount on Axis bank Credit and Debit EMI transactions Here's how
Frequently bought together
Customers who bought this item also bought
About the Author
Arvind Subramanian is currently a professor of public policy at Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government, having served as an economist at the IMF as well as a senior fellow at the Center for Global Development in Washington, DC, and the Peterson Institute for International Economics. He is the author and co-author of several books, including Eclipse: Living in the Shadow of China's Economic Dominance and India's Turn: Understanding the Economic Transformation, among others.
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter mobile phone number.
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Coming to the book, it provides a detailed analysis of the goings-on at the Ministry of Finance, explainations with graphs and rib-tickling anecdotes that will entertain while improving your knowledge. Subramanian's thoughts on demonetisation are especially relevant. An excellent read for anyone who is interested in the goings on at North Block.
Gandhiji said that poverty is the worst form of violence. Even after seventy years of independence, over 20 percent of our people are below the poverty line. Hence, inclusive growth and poverty eradication should be the topmost priority.
Secondly, macroeconomics as a subject is a very complex science. With innumerable variables and situations that are dynamic, tons of data that is often obscure, modelling and forecasting national economic outcomes renders the job of a weatherman, child’s play in comparison.
Finally, in a large democracy with scores of political parties across the country, whose ideologies span the entire spectrum of left to right and swing rapidly based on unpredictable alliances by the day, economic policy making is left to a courageous few to get it right. Policies that succeed in the West can’t be copied in India, for reasons of diversity, culture and other socio-economic considerations. Hence, the CEA needs to be apolitical and sworn to professional integrity with courage to speak the truth, diplomacy to convince the bosses and humility to maintain silence when needed.
Arvind Subramanian excels in all the above criteria in his role as CEA. The quantum and quality of work in making policies that are sound in theory, supported by political bosses and successful in implementation, is outstanding.
There is a brief and brilliant introduction that presciently covers the key points and nudges one to read further. Each chapter is devoted to an important topic. The views in many chapters are contrary to what the Government has done, but then the office of the CEA is advisory in nature. Political compulsions can override sound economic advice, at least in the short run.
His views on demonetization of November 2016 is one such example. He discusses the twin puzzle of political victory in the UP elections, despite the hardships faced by the people, and the economic puzzle of a mere 2 percent blip in the GDP despite 86 percent of the cash being sucked out overnight from the monetary system.
There is a powerful argument to abolish subsidies in agriculture. He discusses two types of agriculture in India. The cereal centric farming is smothered in love benefiting cereal and big farmers while pulses, diary, livestock, oil seeds and vegetables are loved too little in the current policy framework. Minimum Support Price and other subsidies of fertiliser and power to rice farmers is egregious. It is unfair to poorer farmers who cultivate non irrigated crops, impacts depleting water table, worsens soil quality and adds to the already accumulating ‘Kumbakarna-esque’ rice mountains that is left rotting to the rats.
The chapter on Twin Balance Sheet challenge that is plaguing the Banking System with Non-Performing Assets and the core industries like power and steel being bankrupt due to idle assets makes excellent reading. This would perhaps be the most important hurdle to get our way across to kick start the economy. We need to exorcise the ghost of crony capitalism and its new avatar stigmatised capitalism through transparent and clean governance. Focus on 5 R’s – Recognition, Reconciliation, Recapitalization, Reform and Regulation to put Banking back on track.
If there needs to be a serious consideration by the Nobel Committee in awarding a prize in Economics that matters positively to the well being of over a billion people, it should perhaps be awarded to GST in India. Though it is still work in progress in terms of fine tuning of rates and simplification of processes. Arvind Subramanian would surely find his name in the citation.
The book clearly brings out the fact that we need to re-examine our model of ‘Precocious Development’ that has put the proverbial cart before the horse by encouraging services at the neglect of agriculture and industry.
Arvind says that a good CEA should be both Karna and Arjuna. In fact, he needs the unconditional support and choicest blessings of all the three mighty Lords, Vishnu, Shiva and Brahma to re-examine and realign our policies.
We need Vishnu to excel in programs like GST, Make in India and JAM. We need Shiva to gather courage to eliminate outdated schemes that drain revenues and nurture illegal leakages. We need Brahma to fully leverage our creative minds to introduce innovative ideas like QUBI. Together we can banish poverty, usher in prosperity and regain the rightful place under the sun for our great nation.
(Suggestion: ‘The Three Box Solution: A Strategy for Leading Innovation’ by Prof Vijay Govindarajan, is a simple, yet powerful tool worth considering.)
Mahatma Gandhi would certainly bless Arvind for his outstanding work and this book. For a common man like me, it is a huge debt of gratitude to Arvind and Team CEA, that I would never be able to repay. Fortunately, some debts don’t add to our NPAs and need no waivers by politicians.
Thank you, Professor. JAI HIND.
Dr subramanian segues from obstcales of indian economy with command satire and rejoinderd Solutions for the same !!